
This week we are gong to explore a challenge many owners face, often for very different reasons: aggression and irritability. Most dogs demonstrate reactive behavior at some point in their lives, and like any other symptom, it can have many underlying causes.
Before we dive in, please know this, if your dog shows aggression or irritability, they are not a bad dog, and you are not a bad owner. This is communication. Our goal is to understand that communication so you can better advocate for your dog.
Aggression Is Communication
When we look at aggression or irritability through the lens of communication, your dog is using the tools they have to get what they need. If they repeatedly demonstrate a behavior, let’s use growling as an example, it’s likely because it has worked for them in the past.
A growl often makes people uncomfortable and has traditionally been punished, but I would encourage you not to punish or reprimand your dog for this. While we don’t want a dog to feel the need to growl, our goal is not suppression. The goals is for your dog to be comfortable, confidant, and have their needs respected.
When we suppress agitated behavior without addressing the cause, we increase the risk of escalation.
Why Punishment Can Escalate Behavior
Imagine a middle-aged do who has lived in a quiet adult home, is well-exercised and has always done well with people. Now place that dog at a busy family gathering with young children, loud noise, rough petting, being cornered, and unpredictable interactions.
This can quickly become overwhelming. The dog may growl to ask for space, especially if their subtle cues or attempts to retreat have not worked. If that goal is punished and the dog remains in the situation, they may escalate to snapping or lunging the next time they feel the same pressure.
This isn’t a “bad” dog, this is a dog doing its best to cope.
A Better Approach: Responding to Early Signals
Now consider a different response. At the first growl, the dog is calmly removed to a quiet space and given something comforting (many dogs find great relief in a familiar kennel or retreat area).
This is also an opportunity to educate others about how to “listen” to the dog’s signals.
The goal is simple:
Meet the dog’s needs
Reduce the stress that caused the escalation
In the future, that dog is more likely to use earlier, safer communication, like growling, because it worked.
In an ideal world, we would prevent situations that push dogs to this point. But life isn’t always predictable or controllable. If the dog has a history of struggling in a situation, settling them before known stressors is ideal, but not always possible.
When You Need More Support

For many dogs, the ability to de-escalate is a learned skill, and one that can be difficult depending on their past experiences.
When reactive behaviors:
Persist despite addressing triggers
Occur in unavoidable everyday situations
Appears suddenly
…it is time to seek additional support.
In veterinary and training communities, this is often referred to as reactivity or behavior change.
The Importance of a Team Approach
When reactivity is persistent, a team approach is often most effective:
Trainers help teach you and your dog new responses
Veterinarians evaluate for medical causes and provide treatment
In middle-aged to older dogs, irritability, unpredictability, or aggression can be early signs of illness. Pain, whether from injury or chronic conditions, is a very common contributor.
If an underlying medical issue is not well controlled, training efforts have limited results. Many skilled trainers recommend veterinary evaluation before or alongside training. This is a strong sign of an informed approach.
Common Medical Causes of Behavior Changes
Some common contributors include:
Pain (arthritis or underlying illness)
Endocrine diseases affecting hormone balance
Neurologic conditions (such as canine cognitive dysfunction)
Anxiety or compulsive disorders
Behavior is deeply connected to well-being. Any person who has experienced illness or chronic pain understands how much it affects patience and tolerance.
Depending on the cause, improvement may vary. Your veterinarian can help guide expectations, and in complex cases, a veterinary behaviorist may be recommended.
Training Matters: Why Positive Reinforcement Works
Research consistently shows that positive reinforcement training is the most effective way to create lasting behavior change.
Punishment may stop behavior quickly, but through fear
Under stress, those behaviors often return more intensely
Dominance-based training does not address the underlying cause
Our goal is not just compliance, it is helping our dogs feel safe, confident, and capable.
We cannot remove all stress from life, but we can teach our dogs that:
They are safe
They can cope
They can trust us to help when overwhelmed
A Realistic Perspective
Living with a dog who struggles with aggression or irritability is a significant responsibility, and it often requires meaningful lifestyle adjustments.
The hope is always improvement, and in many cases progress does happen:
Sometimes behaviors resolve completely
Often, they become manageable with support
Sometimes challenges remain, but quality of life can still improve greatly
In more difficult cases, where safety risks are high or medical issues cannot be adequately managed, options like rehoming or euthanasia may be discussed. These are deeply emotional and complex decisions, and they are not a reflection of failure. They are, at times, the most compassionate choices available.
You Are Not Alone
It’s important to remember this:
Many dogs with reactivity go on to live safe, happy, and deeply connected lives with their families.
With understanding, the right support, and a willingness to adapt, you can:
Build trust
Improve communication
Create a sense of safety for your dog
You are not alone in this, and there is help, progress and hope ahead.
Dog Sense contains information related to veterinary health care and does not replace veterinary advice. For any concerns about your dog's health, consult your veterinarian. Dog Sense content is not individual advice and should be considered in the context of your dog’s individual health needs.
Dr. C, DVM - a veterinarian who has worked in private practice and animal welfare while occasionally donating her time to research to improve the safety of animal products. Working in animal welfare inspired her to pursue opportunities that foster open educational dialogue that meet people where they are in their lives. In her spare time she enjoys gardening, hiking, and cooking with her family.